Experts choose their favourite graphic

Malofiej 2002: Javier Errea had collected the results of the survey between the 21 experts. Obviously they couldn’t agree on the ‘best graphic’ although Minard’s Napoleon map got two votes.
However, the most successful artist might be Nigel Holmes, who was selected three times.

Below are all the results. Regrettably without the graphics. (- hey, there has to be advantages to show up at the actual conference, eh?)

NAME OF EXPERT	SELECTED GRAPHIC	GRAPHIC ARTIST
Michael Agar, The Observer, UK	IRA Attack on No. 10	Phil Green, The Sunday Telegraph, 10/2 1991
Ricardo Bermejo, Bermejo Communicacíon, Spain	The Fate of Napoleon’s Army in Russia, 1812-13	Charles Minard, 1869
Juan Antonio Giner, Innovation International Media Consulting Group, USA	Bush vs Clinton, US Presidential Election	Nigel Holmes, Time Magazine, 1992
Jeff Goertzen, St. Petersburg Times, USA	The Weather map	George Rorick, USA Today 1982
Phil Green, The Sunday Telegraph, UK	Evolution of the Earth	Ned M. Seidler, National Geographic, August 1985
John Grimwade, Condé Nast Traveler Magazine, USA	New York Axonometric Map	Anderson, August 1985
Karl Gude, Newsweek, USA	Drawings	Leonardo da Vinci, 16th Century
Nigel Holmes, Visual Explanations, USA	London Underground Map from 1932, (1945 version)	Harry Beck
Lucy Lacava, Consultant, Canada	Breitling Emergency Watch: How it works	Frank O’Connell, The New York Times, 2000
Joe Lertola, Time Magazine, USA	Underground – looking into the earth	Ned M. Seidler, National Geographic, 1985
Duncan Mil, Graphic News, UK	Diamonds were a girl’s best friend	Nigel Holmes, Time, 1983
Ole Munk, Ribergaard & Munk, Denmark	A prostitute has been murdered	Erling Nederland, Politiken, 1974
Corrie Parsonson, Reuters News Graphicss Service, UK	Cholera epidemic map in London	John Snow, 1854
Gonzalo Peltzer, El Territorio, Argentina	Soro’s properties	Jaime Serra, Clarin, 1997
George Rorick, The Poynter Institute, USA	The Fate of Napoleon’s Army in Russia, 1812-13	Charles Minard, 1869
Jaime Serra, Spain	Manual of instructions for assembling	Marcel Duchamp, 1966
Jan Schwochow, Max Magazine, Germany	A Monumental Challenge	W. Pitzer, The Charlotte Observer
Geoffrey Sims, The Times, UK	Train Diagram and others	L. Ashwell Wood, Eagle, 1950-1969
Leo Tavejnhansky, O Globo, Brazil	Snoring	Nigel Holmes, US Airways magazine
Miguel Urabayen, University of Navarra	Europe at the frontier of World War 2	Richard Edes Harrison, Fortune, 1938
Juan Velasco, The New York Times, USA	A clock	Unknown

(This article was first published in 2002 in the former version of VisualJournalism.com)

Malofiej-week is here

VisualJournalism - 80% of the news in infographics …

Experts choose their favourite graphic

NAME OF EXPERT

SELECTED GRAPHIC

GRAPHIC ARTIST

Michael Agar, The Observer, UK

IRA Attack on No. 10

Phil Green, The Sunday Telegraph, 10/2 1991

Ricardo Bermejo, Bermejo Communicacíon, Spain

The Fate of Napoleon’s Army in Russia, 1812-13

Charles Minard, 1869

Juan Antonio Giner, Innovation International Media Consulting Group, USA

Bush vs Clinton, US Presidential Election

Nigel Holmes, Time Magazine, 1992

Jeff Goertzen, St. Petersburg Times, USA

The Weather map

George Rorick, USA Today 1982

Phil Green, The Sunday Telegraph, UK

Evolution of the Earth

Ned M. Seidler, National Geographic, August 1985

John Grimwade, Condé Nast Traveler Magazine, USA

New York Axonometric Map

Anderson, August 1985

Karl Gude, Newsweek, USA

Drawings

Leonardo da Vinci, 16th Century

Nigel Holmes, Visual Explanations, USA

London Underground Map from 1932, (1945 version)

Harry Beck

Lucy Lacava, Consultant, Canada

Breitling Emergency Watch: How it works

Frank O’Connell, The New York Times, 2000

Joe Lertola, Time Magazine, USA

Underground – looking into the earth

Ned M. Seidler, National Geographic, 1985

Duncan Mil, Graphic News, UK

Diamonds were a girl’s best friend

Nigel Holmes, Time, 1983

Ole Munk, Ribergaard & Munk, Denmark

A prostitute has been murdered

Erling Nederland, Politiken, 1974

Corrie Parsonson, Reuters News Graphicss Service, UK

Cholera epidemic map in London

John Snow, 1854

Gonzalo Peltzer, El Territorio, Argentina

Soro’s properties

Jaime Serra, Clarin, 1997

George Rorick, The Poynter Institute, USA

The Fate of Napoleon’s Army in Russia, 1812-13

Charles Minard, 1869

Jaime Serra, Spain

Manual of instructions for assembling

Marcel Duchamp, 1966

Jan Schwochow, Max Magazine, Germany

A Monumental Challenge

W. Pitzer, The Charlotte Observer

Geoffrey Sims, The Times, UK

Train Diagram and others

L. Ashwell Wood, Eagle, 1950-1969

Leo Tavejnhansky, O Globo, Brazil

Snoring

Nigel Holmes, US Airways magazine

Miguel Urabayen, University of Navarra

Europe at the frontier of World War 2

Richard Edes Harrison, Fortune, 1938

Juan Velasco, The New York Times, USA

A clock

Unknown

Popular Posts

Editor's Picks

Recent Posts

Categories

Random Posts